Prodigal Magazine

Music is Helping Reshape My Story

I used to look forward to the long months of winter.

Long evenings meant more time to build with LEGOs, to read, to stay indoors. Growing up, that was an idyllic situation for me, as I would rather be inside with my little brother and sister (although I was a bully of an older brother to her) than outside in the cold Northern Michigan winter.

Somewhere back there, as a kid, I spent five or six years studying piano.

My teacher was a woman of my grandparents’ generation, a child prodigy in England who married a trumpeter many years her senior. This chain-smoking couple taught hundreds of students out of their modest home, he in the basement, she in the living room.

How I ended up learning the piano under her tutelage is not clear to me, and it honestly wasn’t a perfect fit. I hated practicing, I did not like most classical music and my asthma made lesson in their home a physical challenge. But she was kind to me and persisted in teaching me, despite my occasional protestations.

My obstinance reached a head as I entered my teenage years.

Despite my teacher’s petitions, even offering to let me skate by without practicing, my pleading eventually pressured my parents into letting me quit. Music had become a chore for me and I needed out. I walked away, big time, but I had more time to go through the normal teenage experiences.

In college I fell in love with an aspiring opera singer and I ended up joining the choir and minoring in music. It was a pragmatic decision to spend time with her while taking music history classes. But I didn’t understand the power and purpose of the music I was studying. It was an academic study but it didn’t resonate inside of me in the way that it did with the girl I was pursuing.

Now we’ve been married six years and I’m spending most nights at home alone —

while she is away working toward her graduate degree in voice. The depression and anxiety that I have been diagnosed with in adulthood make the long winter nights rather miserable, a long way from the joy of basement games in January’s past.

Some nights are nearly crippling.

One recent night, I sat thinking in our dining room, which happens to house my wife’s grandfather’s keyboard. I sat down at the bench on a whim and discovered some old sheet music left by my best friend several summers ago when he roomed with us.  As I struggled through the introductory chords of Ben Fold’s Wandering, a change took place.

Lost in the music, the anxiety calmed and my mood lightened.

It was therapeutic and unexpected. No medication, no breathing exercises. Just music.

I think it was because music is a language, and language is the vehicle used to express every emotion comprehensible. In that moment, the language of peace, of comfort, of the familiar resonated through the chords of a ten year old pop song. They helped pull me through the moments of crushing, irrational fear.

Nietzsche once wrote “without music, life would be a mistake.” Music is making the long nights easier, less empty. When the anxiety or depression creep in, I know that I can sit down at the piano, plunk out a few notes, and eventually lose myself in the music.

Music isn’t a cure all for me and I don’t expect it to be.

Sometimes it doesn’t feel right and I try to turn to other things to calm the stress. But right now I’m relearning what my teacher tried to teach me in her smoked-filled living room. Music is beautiful. Music conveys emotions. Music speaks to the soul.

And for me, and maybe for you, music is helping me reshape my story of cold, lonely, dark winter nights into something bright and beautiful.

[Photo:  Louise Lemettais, Creative Commons]

About The Author

Dean is an Anglican deacon and a high school teacher who loves to read and share stories. Soccer and community-wide shenanigans in Detroit occupy a lot of his time, but his favorite role is as husband and number one fan of his opera singing-wife, Dorcas Giles. You can connect with him by following him on Twitter.

  • Emily_Maynard

    Dean, I was so excited for your first post here, but this blew me away. Thank you for writing with such honesty about a tough place and a tiny glimpse of hope. It’s easy to write about darkness and music in a cliche way, but this piece is fresh and inviting.

    I too, took half-hearted piano lessons growing up. Now I love the fact that I can play a few pop songs with basic chords and 4/4 time (well, mostly it’s just an excuse to belt them out, but still).

    This line is great: “Music isn’t a cure all for me and I don’t expect it to be.”

    Love you, friend. Thanks for inviting us into these tough nights. You are not alone.

    • http://dsimmer.com/ Dean P. Simmer | dsimmer.com

      Thanks Emily, you have been a huge encouragement to me on this journey. I love you too.

  • Ruthie Dean

    Love this article! I’m not a musician, but I have a deep appreciation for what art can do for the soul. I had a very similar experience the first time I was anxiety ridden and sat down to write. It makes the world a little quieter, doesn’t it?

    AND such a small world! I was at y’alls wedding;)

    • http://dsimmer.com/ Dean P. Simmer | dsimmer.com

      Absolutely agreed, it does make the noise a lot quieter and brings some peace.

      Giles showed me a picture the other day of you at our wedding! Small world indeed. :-)

  • http://thomasemason.net/ Thomas Mason

    This is a beautiful story! Music, for me, often brings me out of a slump I’m going through, and gives me hope and encouragement. Sometimes when we make mistakes or come up short in our past, they are used in ways we wouldn’t expect they would to comfort us and to be an example of encouragement and hope for others.

    • http://dsimmer.com/ Dean P. Simmer | dsimmer.com

      Thanks Thomas! It helps to have a musician wife for another source of music too. :-)

  • http://twitter.com/mkmac Matthew K. Mac

    Beautifully written and utterly true.

    • http://dsimmer.com/ Dean P. Simmer | dsimmer.com

      Thanks! And since you’re the cause of my sheet music inventory, you get extra thanks!

  • J. Ann

    Awesome story beautifully written! I took lessons for a year when I was eleven. I hated lessons because I couldn’t read the music. I wanted to play everything by ear, which was easy in the beginning. But the music kept getting harder and I couldn’t keep up. I was too lazy to try hard, that was the bottom line. Eventually, my mom let me quit. I had even won a first place ribbon for my age group for composing my own song. I hated the process though. The interest simply wasn’t there.

    Today, I regret not putting forth the effort. I have all these songs I have written stuck in my head. I can play the melody barely,I just can’t play them, play them. I still struggle to read music, thirty six years later. It is very frustrating!

    I’m glad you started playing again, for whatever reason. I think you should keep it up. I believe everything happens for a reason. There’s a reason why you sat down on that piano bench that night. We all have our outlets. Writing is my outlet…poetry, song lyrics, and inspirational stuff. I don’t share my writing with many people, most times with no one. I’m trying to do better, but boy fear can be crippling, ya know. Writing definately keeps me out of the therapists office, so I’m saving a boatload of money. I hope someday to be able to tell a story as lovely as you have in this piece.

    Thank you for sharing this story, you have inspired me. Who knows, maybe I’ll get out my keyboard and diddle when I get home this weekend.

    God Bless!

    • http://dsimmer.com/ Dean P. Simmer | dsimmer.com

      Thanks for sharing and for your kind words! I definitely understand what you mean about crippling fear and I hope that you will find strength through the Prodigal community and your writing.