Prodigal Magazine

Am I Worth Loving?

I left my jacket at the party.

I walked back to my dorm room, shivering from the chill in the air. The night before, a Friday, I’d spent the night in a guy’s room. He was an upperclassman, I just a freshman in college, and I felt incredibly beautiful with the way he looked at me and touched me.

I made a commitment to save sex for marriage, but nights like that made me question my commitment.

I wanted desperately to make him love me and never stop wanting me.

There I was the next night, walking jacketless back to my dorm. I wore my new skirt and tube top and felt like an idiot, trying to hold back tears until I made it home.

He’d completely ignored me.

The guy I’d spent the night with just 24 hours earlier pretended like he didn’t notice me standing in the fraternity house. He was with another girl—a long-legged, gorgeous blonde and I was pea-green with envy. I kept lingering, hoping he would notice me, hoping she was just his sister or his cousin—not wanting to give up on him just yet.

Then, I saw him kiss her right there in the middle of the dance floor. I grabbed my purse and ran, leaving my jacket in the pile across the room. I couldn’t let him see me crying.

I never wanted to feel utterly forgotten like that again. But that wasn’t the last time.

I tried to date better men, believing I just kept choosing the wrong guy. The next time I questioned if I was even worth a man’s affection, his name was Ryan and he was a senior. I was just a freshman.

After that there was the strong football player who told me I resembled a supermodel (right) as we climbed in the back of an upperclassman’s car. I ended up in his arms at the end of the night. Each of these relationships commenced with an exhilarating flood of emotions, followed by a hard crash into five servings of soft-serve and friends commiserating with me about what a %&*$ he was and how I ‘deserved’ better.

But doesn’t rejection always make us feel like we deserve less?

I’m good at chastising myself, so after a few harsh words and promises to do better and if I’m honest, a good dose of church—my hurting heart seemed to mend. But what I never realized was my decisions to run to men were much deeper. The questions of “Am I worth loving?”

“Am I lovable?”

“Am I beautiful?” screamed louder.

I didn’t believe I was worth loving, but I was desperate to prove I was.

No matter if your life has been idyllic up to this point or wrecked with abandonment and pain—someone at some point has made you feel worthless.

Whether it was a parent who said you’d never measure up, a best friend who left you, or a boy who didn’t choose you, we’ve all had someone reaffirm our doubts that we even deserve love.

I counsel women in messy, hurtful relationships and it’s amazing how each doesn’t believe they deserve better. I’ve learned a lot from dating all the wrong men myself, but I promise you that all our huffing and puffing and striving to prove we are worth a man’s affection is futile.

The reason you can’t be alone, or that you let men text you for a late-night “date” or that lost your virginity to a man that left you when another woman stole his affection is always deeper.

At least it was for me.

We accept the kind of love we think we deserve. That’s the danger in not knowing what you are worth. You will accept disgraceful, hurtful, and often terrible love.

Because you don’t know the depth and the height of the love you deserve. I didn’t either.

I don’t think positive self-talk, only dating “nice guys,” or listening to our friends praises does anything to combat the riddling insecurity many of us face about a man’s affection.

And I don’t believe you can discover you are worth loving in the arms of a man.

I was 8,000 miles from home in a countryside town in China when I finally could believe, though difficult, I am worth loving. Sitting quietly with an elderly Chinese lady, holding her hand, I knew she was worth loving. In fact, I tried desperately to tell her, but she spoke a different dialect and couldn’t understand my Mandarin.

“Mae” lived in a concrete alleyway with no roof over head and had outlived all her children. It was as if with all my emotions and love that flooded into that open-aired, sunny room, God showed her and I we are worth love.

Worth stems from the quiet assurance we are enough—not because of our jeans size, the number of suitors calling, or our resumes—but because of Jesus. He has declared you are not just worth loving, but worth dying for. May you have the strength to run from the temptation to try to prove your worth in the arms of a man.

For that, dear sister, is truly a dead end.

Have you tried to find your worth in a man (or woman)? Will you share your story?

[Photo:  Citoyen du Monde Inc, Creative Commons]

About The Author

Ruthie Dean is a book marketer at Harper Collins Christian by day and a dreamer and writer by night. She and her mustache-enthusiast husband call Nashville home. Their first book, Real Men Don’t Text, will hit bookstores in the Fall of 2013. Ruthie's writing has appeared in Christianity Today, The Angelos, The Good Women Project, and other print and online publications. You can read her blog www.ruthiedean.com and follow her on Twitter.

  • http://twitter.com/MicaelaRose Micaela Hollins

    “And I don’t believe you can discover you are worth loving in the arms of a man.” yes yes yes

    You’ve hit the nail on the head Ruthie! Thank you for writing this and for fighting for the hearts of women.

    • Ruthie Dean

      Thanks Micaela! Good to see you over here;) Hope all is well! I just saw on your blog that you are only 23. You are so mature and godly and encouraging and just WOW. I can only imagine how God will use you in the coming years.

  • http://dsimmer.com/ Dean P. Simmer | dsimmer.com

    Wow, Ruthie, just…wow. Thank you for writing this!

    • Ruthie Dean

      Thanks for reading, Dean!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1581946757 Sarah Hazlewood

    Ruthie- you have no idea how deeply you dug into my soul with this. I’m sitting here with my mind blown & tears in my eyes, knowing now that I’m not the only one like this. Wow
    God bless you.

    • Ruthie Dean

      You are not alone, Sarah. May you find peace in the knowledge you are so worth loving!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Katherine-Harms/602268732 Katherine Harms

    The moment when I understood that I didn’t deserve anything but scorn and punishment is buried very deep in my past, but the moment I discovered that I was actually worth everything came late in life. By that time I had endured many of the experiences you describe, and more, plus a long marriage to a person with no more self-respect than I. He lived out his horror as a controller, and I lived out mine as the victim. After that marriage ended, and after I had with some terror entered into a new marriage, I was in church on Sunday morning. During the morning prayer, the pastor said, ‘Thank you, Lord, that you forgive everything evil in us not because we deserve it, but for Jesus’ sake.” I had heard those words many times before. I had even made a profession of faith and been baptized. But i never really understood how much God loved me before. From the moment of my baptism, I realized that I continued to be sinful, and my relationships with family and “friends” reinforced my image of myself as barely a step short of loathesome. I worked hard to be a perfect little girl so my parents wouldn’t hate me, and I worked hard to be a perfect little Christian so God wouldn’t hate me. My relationships with men were poisoned by the scorn I felt I deserved for being so imperfect.
    That beautiful Sunday morning prayer finally convinced me that Jesus’ love was real. It takes a long time to heal wounds that have laid open for so many years. I felt real kinship when I read of your experience holding that old woman’s hand. That is how I felt during that Sunday morning prayer. It was as if the blinders finally fell off and my life began. I never doubted that Jesus died and rose again for sinners, and that is why I professed my faith at age nine. But it took years for me to understand it. The moment the burden of being perfect lifted off my shoulders was the moment my real life began. Jesus loves me. The real me, The me that, until that moment, did not deserve even to pray for forgiveness.
    Thank you for a great article. I hope many women, especially young women, take it to heart.
    I think churches actually have the wrong goal for their education programs. I truly believe that if Christian education focuses only on what behavior is right or wrong in dating, women come away with the notion that they can behave their way to love and fulfillment. Christian teachers somehow need to do a better job of leading young people to moments such as your moment with the lady in China. It is absolutely worthless to be the fastest person in the world navigating the Bible, it is completely pointless to be able to recite 100 great Bible verses, if in your heart you feel like a worthless person who ought to be kicked around and abused.

    • Ruthie Dean

      Thanks for sharing, Katherine! I love your story. So beautiful how Jesus reaches us all in unique ways.

  • http://www.gritandglory.com/ Alece Ronzino

    “Worth stems from the quiet assurance we are enough…” I am working this year on quieting the din of my fears and insecurities and self-criticizing so I can hear (and start to believe) that quiet assurance…

  • http://twitter.com/Douglas_AmongUs Douglas H.

    It’s the hardest thing in the world sometimes… well, most of the time. Thank you for this.

  • http://www.jesusrockstar.tumblr.com/ Bethany Grace Paget

    I did try. For a really long time. Even after giving my life to Christ and trying to live the “good girl Christian life” I was told I had to live. But it wasn’t enough. I knew Jesus was enough, that the cross satisfied every place in me that felt unworthy of love. Yet it wasn’t until I was able to come face to face with and bring into the light the shame I had been carrying from years of abuse and sexual trauma that I was able to really believe it. Believe it to my core, in my bones. Believe that despite my imperfections He loves me and cherishes me.

    • Ruthie Dean

      Oh Bethany, I hear you. Yes, a blanket “Jesus is enough” never works unless we dig up the dark, decaying place of our hearts.

  • http://thomasmarkzuniga.com/ TMZ

    What a wonderful post. Can completely appreciate this as a guy who’s never dated and often yearns for that same kind of intimate but seemingly forbidden acceptance/worth. What a blessing you must be to the women you counsel. All the best!

    • Ruthie Dean

      Thank you for your kind words, TMZ! Yes, this struggle is not just for women–maybe my husband can write on it next! :)

  • http://profiles.google.com/courtosborn12 Courtney Osborn

    But doesn’t rejection always make us feel we deserve less?? Yes, so true. And then it goes from feeling to believing it and the road to follow, a slippery slope. Thanks for your vulnerability here, I think we can all relate and I think we all crave worth in someone, something. Of course, apart from Christ many of those attempts at finding it leave us all the more empty and broken. A dead end. There is grace, always, praise Jesus. Let us spur one another on to hope in Him alone.

  • http://twitter.com/mattschaar m@

    Thanks much, Ruthie.

    Now, Prodigal, let’s run with this theme of abandonment and rejection and discuss how it can affect men. There’s a whole variety of nuances that will require some exploration, for sure, and in many regards most men have navigated that tumultuous world alone.

    • Ruthie Dean

      I vote my husband, Michael Dean, to write this post! Just this morning, he asked me questions that I’m usually the one asking about acceptance and unconditional love. I’d love to open it up for men to express this same fear, because I think often culture views this vulnerability as “weak”.

  • http://shayes08.blogspot.com/ Sarah Hayes

    I’ve been processing through a lot of this same thing — the question of being worthy — in sessions with my counselor over the last few months. I’ve been involved with (in various levels) three different over the years, and none have been solid believers. My counselor asked me what kept me going, even when the giant red flag of “HE DOESN’T LOVE JESUS” popped up early on. And I finally realized…I didn’t believe I was worth the love of a good Christian man. And that is why I was settling for less. I haven’t dated anyone since my ex and I broke up four months ago, but I’ve already shifted my mentality from, “Well, maybe I can get him to love Jesus…” to “No. You deserve a man who already does.” You are so right in that we only accept the love we think we deserve. Thanks for these thoughts.

    • Ruthie Dean

      Oh Sarah–have been in that exact place. After I became a Christian, I still felt so unworthy of a good Christian man. I just finished writing about this struggle when I met my now husband in our book, Real Men Don’t Text. It’s SO hard to believe we are worth loving, but so freeing when we finally do!

  • http://twitter.com/redshoes7 lesley redshoes

    This sentence leapt off the page for me: “We accept the kind of love we think we deserve.” Thanks for the insight.